Lilly's Brooklyn Black And White Cookies

Lilly’s Brooklyn Black and White Cookies

Lilly’s Brooklyn Black and White Cookies are a true New York–style bakery classic, bringing together nostalgic flavor and timeless appeal in every oversized cookie. Inspired by the iconic cookies found in Brooklyn bakeries, each one features a soft, cake-like base topped with a signature half-and-half icing of rich chocolate and smooth vanilla. Carefully baked to achieve the perfect balance between tender crumb and sweet frosting, these cookies deliver both comfort and indulgence in a single treat.

Perfect for dessert, sharing, or pairing with a cup of coffee or milk, these black and white cookies are as versatile as they are recognizable. Their bold appearance and generous size make them ideal for celebrations, bakery displays, or everyday moments when you’re craving something familiar yet satisfying. Whether enjoyed fresh out of the package or savored slowly, Lilly’s Brooklyn Black and White Cookies offer a classic bakery experience that feels both nostalgic and indulgent.

Taste, Texture & Ingredients
Taste: Mildly sweet vanilla cake paired with creamy vanilla icing and rich chocolate icing for a balanced, classic flavor.
Texture: Soft, moist, cake-like cookie base topped with smooth, slightly firm icing that adds a satisfying finish.
Ingredients: Made with flour, sugar, eggs, butter or oil, cocoa, and vanilla flavoring, baked to capture the authentic taste and texture of traditional black and white cookies.